by Michael Isikoff and Mark Hosenball, Newsweek
Sept. 14, 2005
The Bush administration is continuing to face heavy criticism over the sluggish response of federal agencies, principally the departments of Homeland Security and Defense, to the devastation caused by Hurricane Katrina.
New allegations continue to surface that offers of personnel and material assistance to New Orleans and other areas affected by the storm were held up by bureaucratic red tape. There are also indications that a proposed congressional investigation into government responses to the disaster could itself become bogged down in jurisdictional wrangles and partisan infighting.
One example of the criticisms that are still continuing to surface regarding the Bush administration's slow response to the damage wrought by Katrina comes from Bill Richardson, governor of New Mexico and former secretary of Energy under Bill Clinton. Richardson told NEWSWEEK that on Monday, the day Katrina hit New Orleans, he immediately authorized his state National Guard commander to dispatch 400 New Mexico guardsmen to the disaster area to help out Louisiana state forces. But according to a state official, a hold-up at the Pentagon meant that the New Mexico guardsmen did not actually fly to Louisiana until Friday morning, four days after Richardson authorized them to go.
Richardson said that when he asked his guard commander to explain the delay, he was told the New Mexico troops were not being allowed to travel to the region because of "federal paperwork," which the National Guard bureau at the Pentagon insisted had to be completed. According to Richardson, this paperwork included various authorizations and certifications as well as "transportation waivers." "I remember saying to [the New Mexico guard commander] it's going to be too late" by the time state guardsmen reached the disaster scene, Richardson recalled.
An aide to the governor said that military officials later explained that the troops were not allowed to move until they had been assigned a specific mission to pursue once they got to the disaster region, and the mission assignment did not come through from the Pentagon until late Thursday. A spokesman for the National Guard Bureau at the Pentagon said the bureau worked "as quickly as possible" to move troops to the disaster area as part of "an orderly process."
National Guard troops from other states were not the only would-be rescue and recovery officials whose movement to the disaster scene appears to have been impeded by bureaucratic fumbling. According to a knowledgeable federal source, dozens of officers from one of the Homeland Security Department's own bureaus were also inexplicably delayed in being transported to the region. According to the source, investigators working for the Bureau of Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the plainclothes detective division of Homeland Security also known as ICE, were also put on standby to fly to the Gulf Coast within hours of the hurricane making landfall. However, the orders for the ICE agents to move to the region did not come from Homeland Security headquarters until a couple of days passed, leaving investigators puzzled about the reason for the delay.
Late last week, Federal Emergency Management Agency Director Michael Brown was removed from his temporary appointment as top federal official on the scene of the disaster. On Monday, amid questions about his qualifications for the post-he had previously been a "commissioner" of the International Arabian Horse Association and had no background in emergency management-Brown resigned as FEMA chief and from his position as Homeland Security undersecretary. In a public appearance Tuesday, President Bush acknowledged the faltering response by authorities to Katrina and said: "To the extent that the federal government didn't fully do its job right, I take responsibility."
Additional questions are being raised, however, as to whether Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff, who is supposed to be the president's chief adviser on responses to both natural disasters and man-made catastrophes like terror attacks, was also slow in responding to the multiple crises caused by Katrina. According to a report today by the Knight Ridder newspaper chain, under an order issued by President Bush in 2003, Chertoff, as Homeland Security chief, was in charge of managing the national response to a natural catastrophe. But Knight Ridder cited an internal government memo that indicated that Chertoff did not designate Brown as the Principal Federal Official on the disaster scene until Tuesday, Aug. 30, about 36 hours after the hurricane hit Mississippi and Louisiana. Knight Ridder also suggested that the memo implied Chertoff might have been "confused about his lead role in disaster response."
Senior Homeland Security officials insisted to NEWSWEEK that Knight Ridder's reporters had misread Chertoff's Aug. 30 memo and that the newspaper story contained "significant inaccuracies." According to the department's version, on Saturday, Aug. 27, before the hurricane reached the Gulf Coast, President Bush had signed an order declaring the storm an "incident of national significance," thereby formally triggering the "national response plan," a governmentwide scheme for dealing with any kind of national catastrophe that the Bush administration prepared in response to the 9/11 attacks. According to officials, Chertoff's Aug. 30 memo was only a reminder to other agencies that the president had triggered the plan several days earlier. Officials also said that Knight Ridder had misinterpreted the memo when they suggested that Chertoff might have been confused about his role as the leader of government responses to the disaster. The officials said that when Chertoff's memo talked about his department's role in "assisting" in responding to Katrina-rather than leading the response to the storm-the memo was only referring to the department's role in "assisting" a White House Task Force that had been set up to consider long-term plans for helping areas affected by Katrina to recover and rebuild after the storm.
Aides to Chertoff said that the Homeland Security secretary has been concerned for some time that the department's assorted and far-flung components did not always work well together to respond urgently to crises, and that Chertoff declared a few weeks before Katrina that one of his priorities was trying to get various agencies in his own department to work together more efficiently.
Even before it gets under way, a congressional investigation that is supposed to examine how and where government responses to Katrina failed also seems to be beset by jurisdictional and political squabbles. Rep. Peter King, a New York Republican from Long Island who is in line to become next chairman of the House Homeland Security Committee and, hence, a major player in any legislative-branch inquiry, said that several potential obstacles face congressional leaders as they try to set up their investigation.
For a start, King said, Democrats have vowed to boycott the investigation entirely. In a statement last week, House Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi demanded an independent 9/11-style commission be set up to investigate the response to Katrina and said that she would not appoint any Democrats to serve on the Senate-House Katrina inquiry that the GOP leadership says it is going to set up. "The partisan proposal that Republican leaders outlined yesterday is completely unacceptable. House Democrats will not participate in a sham that is just the latest example of congressional Republicans being the foxes guarding the president's hen house," Pelosi complained.
Republican infighting could also hamper any inquiry. King noted that while the House Homeland Security Committee has jurisdiction over the Department of Homeland Security, its agencies, and any actions or preparations it might make relating to man-made catastrophes like terror attacks, the House Transportation Committee, headed by Rep. Don Young, has jurisdiction over natural disasters. Hence, there is a possibility of jockeying between the two committees over control of the Katrina investigation, if it ever gets going. King said that as he understands it, what GOP leaders want to do is to set up a joint inquiry committee, like the panels that examined the Iran-contra affair and 9/11 background. But in this case, the Senate end of the committee would hold hearings under Senate chairmanship with some House members present, and the House members of the committee would do likewise. King said House GOP leaders have indicated they would like any congressional investigation to be completed-and to produce its final report-by Feb. 15 of next year, which doesn't leave much time for the infighting that is currently bogging the down the whole process.
As originally published
|
|
Aug. 29, 2005:
As Katrina strikes, FEMA urges first-responders not to respond
Sept. 2, 2005:
Who is this incompetent doofus running FEMA?
by Rachel R., Unknown News
Sept. 2, 2005:
Emergency crews turned back by FEMA:
They lacked "the required paperwork"
Sept. 2, 2005:
FEMA won't allow airboats to rescue Katrina victims
Sept. 2, 2005:
Troops sent to New Orleans for "combat operation"
with comments by Rebecca and Helen & Harry Highwater
Sept. 3, 2005:
FEMA chief had to be 'asked to resign' from previous job with horse club
Sept. 3, 2005:
FEMA turned back 500-boat rescue flotilla
Sept. 3, 2005:
Bush declares "zero tolerance" for New Orleans
survivors seeking food and water
Sept. 3, 2005:
Thousands of New Orleans refugees held at gunpoint,
not allowed to leave growing hell of Superdome
with comments by Helen & Harry Highwater
Sept. 3, 2005:
Homeland Security stops Red Cross from bringing food for New Orleans
with comments by Sir J and Helen & Harry Highwater
Sept. 3, 2005:
Police official says Nat'l Guardsmen 'played cards' amid New Orleans chaos
Sept. 4, 2005:
Red tape keeps hundreds of doctors from helping hurricane survivors
Sept. 4, 2005:
Homeland Security Chief says New Orleans disaster couldn't have been predicted
with comments by Helen & Harry Highwater
Sept. 4, 2005:
College sophomores used fake press passes to circumvent FEMA's rescue roadblocks
with comments by Helen & Harry Highwater
Sept. 4, 2005:
Navy hospital & water purification ship anchored on nearby coast, underused
Sept. 4, 2005:
FEMA turns down water, fuel for New Orleans, cuts area's emergency communication line
Sept. 5, 2005:
FEMA "dragging its feet" as businesses try to help hurricane, flood victims
Sept. 5, 2005:
Firefighters waited five days for FEMA's OK to enter New Orleans, then gave up, returned to Houston
Sept. 6, 2005:
Now is the time for pointing fingers
by John M., Unknown News
Sept. 6, 2005:
No food drops planned for New Orleans
with comments by Helen & Harry Highwater
Sept. 6, 2005:
U.S. military smuggled white vacationers out of New Orleans Superdome squalor
with comments by Helen & Harry Highwater
Sept. 6, 2005:
As New Orleans waits, FEMA sends firefighters to seminar, assigns them to hand out fliers
Sept. 6, 2005:
New Orleans during the disaster:
Police lied to survivors, blocked escape from city
by Larry Bradshaw and Lorrie Beth Slonsky, EMS NetworkFrom inside New Orleans as the crisis worsened, these survivors found that the authorities were never any help, and often an ugly enemy. =H&HH= | LINK
Sept. 6, 2005:
FEMA head specifically ordered lackadaisical response to "near catastrophic" Hurricane Katrina
Sept. 7, 2005:
International offers of help came immediately, but U.S. approval was delayed by days
Sept. 7, 2005:
FEMA's top-level management stacked with Bush's cronies
with comments by Helen & Harry Highwater
Sept. 8, 2005:
FEMA contractors arrested for looting
with comments by Underground Panther in the Sky
Sept. 8, 2005:
Katrina survivors "evacuated" at the point of a gun
with comments by Helen & Harry Highwater
Sept. 8, 2005:
Canadian search-and-rescue team first to reach New Orleans suburb
Sept. 9, 2005:
"Mission accomplished" in New Orleans
by Harry Highwater, Unknown News
Sept. 9, 2005:
Homeowners' guns confiscated in New Orleans, police threaten evacuation by force
with comments by Sir J and Helen & Harry Highwater
Sept. 10, 2005:
FEMA sent back German plane carrying fifteen tons of food for hurricane victims
Sept. 11, 2005:
Experts question how much looting and mayhem really took place in New Orleans
with comments by The Coyote and Helen & Harry Highwater
Sept. 11, 2005:
New Orleans doctors had to kill their patients
Sept. 11, 2005:
Sheriff threatens to arrest FEMA officials
Countermands FEMA order that stores remain closed
Sept. 11, 2005:
Bush signs executive order lowering wages across Katrina-devastated areas
with comments by Helen & Harry Highwater
Sept. 12, 2005:
Racist police blocked bridge and forced evacuees back at gunpoint
with comments by Chris M. and Helen & Harry Highwater
Sept. 13, 2005:
Chertoff delayed federal response to Katrina disaster, memo shows
Sept. 13, 2005:
As bodies are recovered, reporters are threatened: 'No photos, no stories'
Sept. 16, 2005:
Doctor says FEMA ordered him to stop treating hurricane victims
|
|
Say it with a bumper sticker
$3 each, or two for $5
| All republished material is copyrighted by its original publisher.
It is reprinted by Unknown News without permission, solely for purposes of criticism, comment, and news reporting, in accordance with the Fair Use Guidelines of copyright material under § 107 of U.S.C. Title 17:
Notwithstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any other means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright. In determining whether the use made of a work in any particular case is a fair use the factors to be considered shall include --
(1) the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes;
(2) the nature of the copyrighted work;
(3) the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and
(4) the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.
The fact that a work is unpublished shall not itself bar a finding of fair use if such finding is made upon consideration of all the above factors. |
|
|
There's much more than this at Unknown News.
|
