Welcome to UNKNOWN NEWS
"News that's not known, or not known enough."
Helen & Harry Highwater's cranky weblog of news and opinion.
Home  |  About us  |  Contact us  |  Daily headlines  |  Dialogue  |  Guidelines  |  Index  |  Mystery links  |  Stickers & stuff  |
Commentary    by    J.S.    Magruder
JS's PREVIOUS COLUMN       LATEST COLUMN       NEXT COLUMN
   
There's big money in poverty

by JS Magruder, Unknown News
whynotresist.blogsome.com       January 14, 2008

Everything's an industry. From prisons to mercenaries to the local food pantry -- each has an agenda focused to keeping their organization/institution functioning. Privatizing these institutions only takes them farther away from the actual people impacted by them. The impact of privatizing prisons and armies are pretty well understood (if denied) but the industry providing services to "the poor" is a little less looked at, unfortunately.

Organizations that deal with issues related to poverty like to blather on at length about the difficulties associated with the "War on Poverty". The United States could easily end domestic poverty tomorrow, but we'd have to begin by sacking all the people who work in the poverty industry.

It sounds great to have Public/Private Partnerships, but it assumes that both institutions have the same goals. Perhaps they do share one goal -- keeping the poor, poor. These programs are not about eradicating poverty -- they promote it, because it is profitable.

A few pieces of fruit sent home in a child's rucksack each Friday isn't going to ensure proper nutrition. It does however provide a lesson in humiliation and one's place in the class system. It requires an organization to put the program together, to distribute the rations, to do the paperwork establishing eligibility. The counselors, the job trainers, the parenting coaches --
 
We seem to be (as a nation) suffering a collective case of misplaced hostility.

It isn't the poor taking your money.

It isn't the immigrant family down the street taking your job.

Your jobs were sent abroad by the people representing you in Washington.

Your taxes are torturing and killing people the world over.

Your hard-earned money is funding the building of more prisons to house petty criminals, and for the police helicopter looking for God only knows what.

The people who are making you work longer hours for less pay aren't the poor asking for change on a street corner.

The poor didn't jack up your credit card rates to what any other country in the world would consider usury.

The guy sitting on the park bench with everything he owns in the world stuffed into a paper bag, with maggot-infested unhealed flesh wounds -- that guy didn't sell you the interest-only mortgage.

Go ahead, pat yourself on the back for walking past him as though he didn't exist and make you feel better by mumbling about "services being available."
everyone gets a piece of the action that assumes the poor created their circumstances and can be brought-up if only they will follow the steps laid out for them by the teams of poverty eradicating professionals.

You can read about the latest exercise in my part of the country, here. They plan to have a lot of meetings and knock on many doors. In the meantime, they'll hand out fruit and send people from one place to another seeking whatever small pittance they are able to get for leaping through the
  assigned number of hoops and showing proper deference. You know, because we're bettering them.

Blessed are the poor, my ass. "Rooting Out Poverty?" Do they use specially trained dogs and pigs like the ones that hunt truffles? The whole "rooting out" image works to further dehumanize people living in poverty -- like animals in burrows that need to be rooted out into the daylight. I keep envisioning a living game of Whack-a-Mole with the mallet being the service agencies.

Of course there are people who qualify for assistance but don't apply -- who would want to go through the condescending routine of applying? It's not surprising that people prefer going hungry to having their lives intruded upon by teams of "professionals." I wonder, how much does
the "Director of Grants" in the article make a year?

Bah.

Hand out the money to those who need it. Provide the healthcare. Provide the housing. We could do it right now, but the population has been trained to believe that public assistance is somehow striking it rich and that no-one would ever work again if it were available. In just under thirty years, we've managed to convince people that drawing the dole is not only enough to survive on (it isn't) but that it's the good life. Thanks, Reagan. It was bad enough when the well to do held these views, but when the poor started attacking the poorer I knew we were screwed.

There was a time when it would have been considered impolite to suggest that the less fortunate were unworthy of help. Today it's a badge of honor to walk past someone begging alms. People brag about denying people a few pennies.

We seem to be (as a nation) suffering a collective case of misplaced hostility. It isn't the poor taking your money. It isn't the immigrant family down the street taking your job. Your jobs were sent abroad by the people representing you in Washington. Your taxes are torturing and killing
people the world over. Your hard-earned money is funding the building of more prisons to house petty criminals, and for the police helicopter looking for God only knows what. The people who are making you work longer hours for less pay aren't the poor asking for change on a street corner. The poor didn't jack up your credit card rates to what any other country in the world would consider usury. The guy sitting on the park bench with everything he owns in the world stuffed into a paper bag, with maggot-
infested unhealed flesh wounds -- that guy didn't sell you the interest-only mortgage. Go ahead, pat yourself on the back for walking
 
past him as though he didn't exist and make you feel better by mumbling about "services being available."

Maybe someone will "Root him out" and give him a piece of fruit and a lecture about getting his GED.

© by the author.

 
We're usually unable to forward readers'
emails, but both readers and authors are
invited to visit our 'dialogue' page
for two-way communication:
unknownnews.org/dialogue.html
 

This is an archived Unknown News page. For newest material, visit our main page.


 
YOU CAN HELP

We try not to whine too much or too loudly, but we are poor and this site eats a lot of time and especially money.

Just a buck or two can make all the difference and help keep Unknown News alive.

 
Donations        Sponsorships
Stickers and stuff for sale
Subscriptions        Wish list        Thank you

 
 
 < Please buy a sticker
so the site won't flicker.
 





































 
  Unknown News
This is who we are,
what we do, and why we do it