Welcome to UNKNOWN NEWS
"News that's not known, or not known enough."
Helen & Harry Highwater's cranky weblog of news and opinion.
Home  |  About us  |  Contact us  |  Daily headlines  |  Dialogue  |  Guidelines  |  Index  |  Mystery links  |  Stickers & stuff  |
Dialogue    (Letters to the editor)
 
  Current week's news           Daily headlines         Latest commentary         Latest dialogue       This page is archived as  unknownnews.org/080412-sdM7-HRMD.html
 
   
We are all insurgents at heart

by Herb Ruhs, MD

Apr. 7, 2008
 PERMANENT LINK 
Popularly-based guerilla wars (as opposed to politically-based guerilla wars that are totally dependent on outside vested interests, such as are sweeping Africa now) are nearly completely misunderstood by all commentators, left and right, and by the world's major militaries who fight them. That is why I am startled to run across any commentary that shows even some under-
standing of guerilla resistance fighting, as does Gary Brecher in his Alternet piece "How the U.S. just got schooled by a 'rag-tag' neighborhood army in Iraq."

In popular guerilla wars people fight for the lives, rights and interests of their families and neighborhoods. This was true in our own War of Independence. It was true in Viet Nam, and it is true in Iraq, as Mr. Brecher points out. Given personal exposure to the resistance fighters in Iraq, most ordinary US citizens would become sympathetic toward them and come to despise our own army that is attempting to kill
The truth is that if you want to fight a whole people, the only possible avenue to "Victory" is total, or near total, genocide, such as was pursued in the American Indian Wars.

It is a mark of social progress that such openly genocidal campaigns of conquest have become unacceptable to the conscience of the world.

Now, aims of conquest must be pursued covertly under the cover of "bringing democracy" or "fighting terrorism."
people who are just trying to protect their families.

Of course, in war there are seldom any actual good guys, but there are often a lot of people who think of themselves that way, and fight and die for what they hold dear regardless of the fact that they are consistently used and abused by various power centers. The only way to win against such people is to kill their children before they are able to hold a gun.

In order to survive my five unarmed years as a civilian aid worker in Viet Nam, during the worst years of that war, I had to understand, in a way that the vast majority of foreigners who traveled under armed escort could not, what that war was really about. I had to continually prove my status as a non-combatant and politically non-aligned interloper in order to stay alive. Countless opportunities were presented to me, most accidentally, but some deliberately as tests, to inform on the activities of the resistance. I am still amazed that I managed to thread my way through this obstacle course and stay alive and unwounded (not counting my multiple cancers and other problems related to Agent Orange exposure).

I suspect that those few independent aid workers in close contact with ordinary Iraqis who have survived their stays in Iraq (are there any?) would understand when I say that I have yet to see anything written about the American War in Viet Nam that even comes close to portraying accurately the experience of ordinary Vietnamese during that war. Any such surviving foreign civilian aid workers in Iraq likely feel equally alienated by press and scholarly accounts about the American War in Iraq.

But then, it needs to be this way. The greatest weakness of the foreign aggressor is his irreducible ignorance about the ground level realities of his resistance enemy. I suspect as well that there are numerous people in the US military who do understand what is going on in Iraq -- for example, General William Odum -- but I am also sure that their understanding and wisdom are rejected out of hand by America's dominant, crazed, racist and imperialist military leadership, because their message is not one of "Victory" in a conflict where thoughts of victory are impossible, irrational, and frankly insane.

The truth is that if you want to fight a whole people, the only possible avenue to "Victory" is total, or near total, genocide, such as was pursued in the American Indian Wars.

It is a mark of social progress that such openly genocidal campaigns of conquest have become unacceptable to the conscience of the world. Now, aims of conquest must be pursued covertly under the cover of "bringing democracy" or "fighting terrorism."

But this formal restraint does put the initiative in the hands of resistance fighters who are willing to endure the punishment of aerial bombardment, uranium weapons, cluster bombs and white phosphorus and the ten to one or greater discrepancies in wounded and dead fighters that that the use of those terrible weapons implies, not to mention the vast numbers of civilian casualties, which are now termed "collateral damage" in Newspeak.

Would the citizens of the US be willing to endure such suffering in order to defend our sovereignty from foreign conquerors? Maybe.

***           ***           ***
If the politics of a country are led by people who organize their lives around getting rich, then the military of that society is inevitably going to look like a tool to use to get richer.

Herb Ruhs, MD 

Kathleen R. replies
unknownnews@inbox.com





DISCLAIMER FOR DUMMIES

Our front page is free from nudity and profanity, but interior pages and external links may not be safe for work, and you may be shocked, offended, or in trouble with your boss. A link doesn't imply that we agree with every sentence and every sentiment on every site we link to. We use our noggins, and suggest you use yours.

Anything sent to Unknown News may be published. If you don't want it published, say so plainly. Of course, we publish all incoming hate mail.



 
We sell our own progressive bumper stickers:

pro-peace,
anti-Bush,
pro-freedom,
anti-Republican
stickers you won't
find anywhere else.

$3 each or two for $5

bumper stickers
 
Unknown News is more fun and more informative with your participation, so please don't be shy. Consider yourself invited to speak your mind.

Because we respect peoples' privacy, we do not keep records of friends' and contributors' contact information. This means we can't forward private communications between readers and writers, but we always welcome dialogue for publication.

When we publish incoming emails, we usually edit out the sender's last name, email address, or anything else that would tend to uniquely identify the author (if we slip up, please let us know). But if your email is unambiguously intended only to annoy, insult, or threaten us, we'll publish all the details, and leave it on-line forever.

 We're especially interested in hearing and considering different perspectives. All we ask is that you conduct yourself sanely and civilly. For the most productive dialogue, it helps if you'll cite a specific article or concept we've gotten wrong.

You can contact Helen & Harry at <newsuneed at yahoo.com>. If that address ever fails, our back-up email address is <unknownnews at inbox.com>.

But please, don't email us unless you're really and truly, honestly, actually trying to send the publishers of News a communication you're not sending to anyone or everyone else.

Please don't send attachments or other cr*p we don't want.

If you're trying to reach us but getting no reply, it's probably because you've sent us cr*p we don't want, so we're filtering your emails into the trash, unopened and unread.

If you'd like to have your email address unblocked, simply send a sincere apology (from an un-blocked email address).


YOU CAN HELP
 We try not to whine too much or too loudly, but we are poor and this site eats a lot of time and especially money. Just a buck or two can make all the difference and help keep Unknown News alive.

Donations        Sponsorships        Stickers and stuff for sale
Subscriptions        Wish list        Thank you

   
  The dialogue page is our "letters to the editor" section. To participate, email your comments to newsuneed at yahoo.com.

  Unknown News
This is who we are,
what we do, and why we do it
.
 
QUICK CLICKS  for  DIALOGUE:
 DIALOGUE BY DATE     DISCLAIMER     HATE MAIL     LATEST DIALOGUE     YOU CAN HELP