Welcome to UNKNOWN NEWS "News that's not known, or not known enough."
Helen & Harry Highwater's cranky weblog of news and opinion.
Available in weekly or daily dosage.
Home  |  About us  |  Contact us  |  Daily headlines  |  Dialogue  |  Guidelines  |  Index  |  Mystery links  |  Stickers & stuff  |
  PREVIOUS DAY'S DIALOGUE              Dialogue  for  Monday, August 11, 2008              NEXT DAY'S DIALOGUE  
 
  Current week's news           Daily headlines         Latest commentary         Latest dialogue       This page is archived as  unknownnews.org/d0808-11HR.html
 
   
A rough millennium for the mentally lazy

by Herb Ruhs, MD       Monday, August 11, 2008         PERMANENT LINK  

Re Back along the trail by Herb Ruhs, MD

I remain convinced that the fundamental political issue is what people BELIEVE human nature to be. Simplistic visions melt in the face of the mass of complex and often contradictory evidence provided by archeology and evolutionary biology and hopefully are replaced by a more mature,
nuanced understanding of ourselves.

The first step is to abandon the childish notion, that my five year old grandson just abandoned, that humans are a special case of biology, that we are not animals. We're pretty interesting and in many ways unique animals, but animals none the less, and as subject to scientific investigation as the other animals and with pretty much the same tools.

I see an interesting paradox developing as this disinterested attitude of scientific inquiry into "human nature" develops. As man is brought down a few notches in our own estimation, the rest of the animal kingdom is elevated in proportion. It used to be considered the sin of "anthropomorphizing" to talk about animals having feelings, of
It has been a rough millennium for the mentally lazy.

Forced to accept that Earth wasn't even the center of the Universe, much less the center of the solar system; Forced to accept that internal mental processes condition what we experience as "objective reality"; Forced to abandon ideas of racial superiority (big rearguard action there):

And now thinking people are forced to give up the idea of that special covenant with God that we believed placed us in the position to dominate and endlessly exploit the Earth and all its life.
experiencing emotional pain, but now respectable scientists speak freely of the functions of the limbic system (the part of the brain most associated with feeling states) playing the same role in animals as humans.

It has been a rough millennium for the mentally lazy. Forced to accept that Earth wasn't even the center of the Universe, much less the center of the solar system; Forced to accept that internal mental processes condition what we experience as "objective reality"; Forced to abandon ideas of racial superiority (big rearguard action there): And now thinking people are forced to give up the idea of that special covenant with God that we believed placed us in the position to dominate and endlessly exploit the Earth and all its life.

Of course, the non-thinking majority seems hell-bent on ignoring this new truth and proceeding with its self destructive orgy of mass consumption of resources and destruction of the very life support system of the planet. If we do make it through the current mess it will be because a sufficient number of people came to accept the diminished and more objectively understood role of man in the dance of life, just as a sufficient number of people came to accept that Earth was not the center of the Universe.

The good news and the bad news is that we, or at least our children, are likely to be around to witness the outcome. We may yet achieve universal salvation from ourselves.

Herb Ruhs, MD
My own time is dwindling, and with a little good luck I won't be around to see the outcome of this unfolding choice. Which is really just as well. I try hard to share your optimism, Doc, to believe that we the people will make the right choice, maybe learn to do the dance of life with our feet and bodies instead of with weapons of mass destruction... but even if humanity surprises me and makes the intelligent decision to survive, the transition period will be a lot of hard work, and I'm tuckered already, aren't you?
Helen & Harry

In body yes, in soul no. Maybe part of the difference is that I learned to laugh at the odds at an early age. After all, the odds said I would be in prison, dead or maybe worse. I have so much experience "beating the odds" that I don't take them seriously.

To me what can be is much more important that what is likely to be. But I don't consider myself an optimist, by the way. Optimists miss out on all the pleasant surprises.

***           ***           ***
Re To the letter by SirJ

Readers interested in the Ivins drama should be directed to blog of Meryl Nass at http://anthraxvaccine.blogspot.com/2008/08/beyond-reasonable-doubt.html.

I also recommend Glen Greenwald's work on Salon.com.

Herb Ruhs, MD
      unknownnews@inbox.com



   

Dialogue  for
Monday, August 11, 2008 

Anthrax unlikelihood by Chris D.
It happens weekly, or daily by Dillon
Remember this... by Kathy Fisher
A symptom of Alzheimer's by JR Mooneyham
A rough millennium for the mentally lazy by Herb Ruhs, MD
Fully equipped by the US by SirJ
What's going on in South Ossetia, Georgia? by Marie K.
Gerald Ford: FBI informant by Rebecca
Tall tales told by Heidi Papademetriou

The dialogue page is our "letters to the editor"
section. To participate, email your comments to unknownnews at inbox.com.



  Unknown News
This is who we are,
what we do, and why we do it
.
 
QUICK CLICKS  for  DIALOGUE:
 DIALOGUE BY DATE     DISCLAIMER     HATE MAIL     LATEST DIALOGUE     YOU CAN HELP 






UNKNOWN NEWS mystery links
Links in red are not safe for work, and links in pink include audio and/or video.